Which Is Healthier Bone Broth Or Stock?

Which Is Healthier Bone Broth Or Stock?

You decide to go to the grocery store to get some chicken broth so that you may use it in a dish, but once you get there and are standing in the soup aisle, you are at a loss for what to choose. There is a wide variety of choices, including broth, bone broth, stock, as well as organic and low-sodium variants. What are the key differences, and which option is best for you?

According to Amy Keating, R.D., a nutritionist at CR, stock and broth can both be created from a combination of chicken meat and bones (along with veggies and seasonings), but stock and bone broth often require more bones than ordinary broth does, and regular broth uses more meat than stock does. At Bone Broth, we provide an extensive selection of the best chicken bone broth.

The collagen in the bones, which is produced during the cooking process, is the source of protein, and the more bones that are utilized, the higher the protein content will be; this will also slightly increase the number of calories.

Because it is used more frequently as a foundation in recipes that call for additional seasoning, the stock typically has a lower salt content than broth does. A product with the label “low sodium” indicates that it contains 140 mg of sodium or less per serving. A product with the label “lower” or “reduced” sodium indicates that it contains at least 25 percent less sodium compared to the regular product of the same brand.


What’s the difference between broth and stock?

Even though the phrases stock and broth are sometimes used interchangeably, there is a significant difference between the two. Rumsey explains that stock is formed from bones and has a more substantial consistency as a result of the collagen protein that leaks out of the bones during the cooking process. On the other hand, unlike stock, broth “is produced solely from meat and/or veggies and is more watery.” The essential distinction is that bones are included in stock. There are no bones in the broth.

According to Grinshpan, a common misunderstanding is that stock and broth are interchangeable terms for the same item. “There are three primary distinctions between stock and broth, the first of which are the elements that are utilized to make each one. The animal bones used to make stock are reduced throughout the cooking process, whereas broth typically also contains larger pieces of meat scraps in addition to the bones. When compared to stock, broth typically has a more concentrated consistency.”

The amount of time it takes to cook is yet another point of differentiation. According to Grinshpan, “since the broth is cooked with the added flavor of meat, it is usually simmered for a shorter period of time than stock, around 2 hours, leaving you with a more flavorful cooking liquid.” “Since broth is cooked with the added flavour of meat, it is generally simmered for a shorter amount of time than stock, around 2 hours.” On the other hand, “on the flip side,” stock can be simmered for anywhere between two and six hours in order to extract the flavour of the animal bones.

The use of seasoning is the subject of the third distinction that may be made between the two liquids. According to Grinshpan, the stock is not seasoned very often, although the broth is almost always seasoned.

However, there is one component that the two have in common that makes them comparable. Both broth and stock often begin with a mixture of aromatics and mirepoix, which is a combination of carrot, celery, and onion that has been diced and combined with water.


Wait, what is broth exactly? I need more information.

In the past, the stock was traditionally prepared by utilizing the bones of an animal, such as a chicken. The bones were cooked in a liquid known as “mirepoix,” which is a combination of onions, carrots, and celery. Chefs would stew the bones in the concoction. To make stock, you don’t need any meat at all, but you can incorporate meat if you’d like. The bones are the most essential part of the structure. Cooking time for the stock is anywhere from 2 to 6 hours typically.

In other words, despite its name, bone broth is not actually a broth at all. It’s easy to get the two terms confused because bone broth is considerably more comparable to stock than it is to the broth. However, bone broth is not the same as stock or ordinary broth because it is cooked for a longer period of time than either of those two types of broth. According to most kitchens, bone broth is simmered on the stove for at least 12 hours. Discover more startling dietary facts like this one that could influence the way you now approach your diet.

The collagen protein that is extracted from the bones that are used to manufacture stock is what gives the stock its thick consistency. Because the collagen protein is absent from the broth, the broth is the more watery of the two liquids. Despite this, it can still be a good source of nutrients!

Rumsey argues that the answer is dependent on the ingredients that are added to the soup. “Different ingredients supply different nutrients. For instance, vegetable broth may include a bigger variety of vitamins, but not very much protein.” You’ll need meat broth (or real stock) for it. “Different foods provide different nutrients.” Are you interested in chicken bone broth? No need to look any further! You won’t have any problems using Bone Broth.

According to the USDA Nutrient Database, the following is the nutritional information for one cup of chicken broth:

  • 14 calories
  • 5 mg potassium
  • 100 IU vitamin A
  • 900 mg sodium
  • 1 g carbohydrates
  • 1 g fat
  • 1 g sugar
  • 0 g protein
  • 0 g fiber


What is the stock? I need more info on that, too

A culinary liquid that is prepared by simmering meat, most commonly with mirepoix, is referred to as broth. When it comes to the stock, bones play the same role that flesh does. It is essentially the opposite of stock in that, while bones may be used in the preparation of the broth, doing so is not required, and the primary component of the broth is meat. The cooking time for broth is typically much less than that of stock (under 2 hours).

When it comes to chicken, the most notable distinction between broth and stock is still that the former includes meat while the latter includes bones. According to Fine Cooking, there is no distinction between veggie stock and vegetable broth when it comes to vegetables because veggies do not contain bones or meat. This is because vegetables do not have either of these ingredients.

During the lengthy cooking process, the collagen, vitamins, and minerals that are present in the bones become absorbed into the stock.

When bones are boiled for a longer period of time, more collagen and bone marrow are released, which in turn causes the stock to become more nutrient-dense.

The specific vitamins and minerals that can be found in stock, such as calcium and vitamin D, are different depending on the components that were used to produce them. Rumsey is quick to point out that “Different substances supply different nutrition.” If you want the stock to have a higher vitamin and mineral content, you can make it by adding extra vegetables and herbs to it.

According to the USDA’s Nutrient Database, the following is the nutritional information for 1 cup of chicken stock:

  • 0.5 g fat
  • 2 g carbohydrates
  • 2 g sugar
  • 3 g protein
  • 29 calories
  • 12 mg vitamin C
  • 101 mg potassium
  • 600 mg sodium

The Basic Difference

The most basic explanation is that bones are utilized in the production of stock, whereas flesh is the primary ingredient in broth.

A more in-depth look: Whether it’s homemade or store-bought, the stock gets all the good stuff. The gelatin and proteins that are released from simmering the bones produce a flavour that is more robust and complex. In addition, the stock is helped along with mirepoix, which is a posh French phrase for the combination of diced carrots, celery, and onion, as well as aromatics like herbs and bay leaves, and it is allowed to simmer for a considerable amount of time. On the other hand, the broth gets most of its flavor from the meat, and because it simmers for a shorter amount of time, it has a flavor that is not quite as powerful and typically contains more sodium.

Protein and Sodium

If you are wanting to increase the amount of protein that you consume on a daily basis, it is recommended that you consume stock rather than broth; nevertheless, it is important to keep in mind that stock on its own is not a substantial source of protein. Although ordinary store-bought broth often has a higher salt content than regular store-bought stock, the latter typically has less sodium per serving (140 mg or less) than the former. Choose lower- or reduced-sodium varieties of either stock or broth if you are controlling the amount of sodium you consume. This indicates that there is 25% less sodium in these products compared to the usual versions of the same product. Bone Broth in Melbourne is home to a diverse selection of the city’s top chicken bone broth.


Homemade or Store-bought

Making your own stock and/or broth from home can be beneficial in a number of ways. You have more influence over how it tastes and how much sodium is added (by means of a table or kosher salt), and it is the ideal location to use up vegetable leftovers or the leftover bones from rotisserie chickens. Both can be refrigerated and kept for up to three months in boxes that are suitable for freezing. You can also pour your homemade liquid gold into empty ice cube trays, freeze them until they are solid, then take them out and store them in freezer-safe bags. You can then add them to sauces or use them to thin out soups and stews as needed.

There are a variety of high-quality stocks and broths that can be purchased, which is fortunate because not everyone has the time to prepare their own from scratch.


Flavour Tip

If you are using a product with lower sodium content, then you need to remember to season the food with a little bit of salt as it cooks. A little bit of salt added to vegetables as they sweat at the beginning of the cooking process can make a significant impact on the final product, giving you a greater flavour with less sodium.


And the Winner Is

Stock! In comparison to the broth, it often has less salt and more protein per serving, regardless of whether it was cooked at home or purchased from a store. In addition, the flavor is simply enhanced, which indicates that you will begin with something that is more flavorful and, presumably, will require less salt to achieve the desired level of flavor in the end.



If you’re limiting your salt intake but don’t wish to sacrifice flavour, the low-sodium broth is a wonderful backup option for you to have.


Nutrition Label Cheat Sheet

  • Because neither stock nor broth is particularly rich in protein on its own, you should focus more on the amount of sodium they contain.
  • In order for a product to be considered low in salt, each serving should have no more than 140 milligrams.
  • Keep in mind that ordinary versions of stock and broth contain around 25% more sodium than lower or reduced-sodium versions of both of these ingredients.


So, how do I make chicken stock?

Are you craving a steaming dish of something scrumptious to satisfy your hunger? Grinshpan has got you covered with a straightforward recipe for chicken stock.

Grinshpan believes that roasting the chicken bones while making stock gives it a richer flavor, and she recommends doing so. If you are in a time crunch, however, you do not need to complete this step.

She recommends slicing nearly 2 carrots, 2 yellow onions with the skin on, and 3 to 4 stalks of celery into large pieces if you want to keep things straightforward and conventional. But Grinshpan finds it fun to throw in whatever vegetables she happens to have in her own kitchen. “I love adding parsnip, 2 halves of lemons, fresh turmeric, and a head or 2 of garlic (without the tops),” she says. “It adds a lot of flavors.”

Note that around 4 pounds of chicken bones are required for this recipe.

  1. Turn your oven’s temperature up to 450 °F.
  2. In a large roasting pan, toss chicken bones and any veggies you happen to have on hand with olive oil. Roast until chicken is cooked through.
  3. Place the mix in the oven and cook it for 30 to 40 minutes, or until it is fragrant and golden brown.
  4. Bring a big pot of water to a boil, then add the bones to the pot.
  5. Reduce the heat, and continue cooking at a low simmer for many hours.


Okay, so, stock vs. broth: Which is healthier?

The main difference between chicken broth and chicken stock is that chicken broth is created from the raw meat of the bird, while chicken stock is made from the bones and other byproducts of the animal. In the end, the distinction comes down to the components. According to the kitchen, another distinction between stock and broth is that the latter typically contains seasoning while the former does not. Stock, on the other hand, does not contain any seasoning.

When it comes to flavor, the broth is typically more robust, whereas stock is known for having a fuller, more pillowy mouthfeel. It takes quite some time to extract all of the collagen and gelatin existing in the bones that are used to produce the stock, whereas extracting all of the flavors from the meat is a somewhat quicker process. This is another reason why making stock takes longer than making broth. No, stock and broth are not the same things; this is one of the widespread misconceptions about food that simply isn’t the case.

In most cases, stock and broth are relatively comparable to one another. On the subject of health, however, Rumsey provides the stock with a marginal advantage. According to Rumsey, “both broth and stock provide a great variety of nutrients; however, the stock is typically more nutrient-dense because it contains more carbohydrates, fat, protein, and vitamins/minerals.”Coupon, on the other hand, is more nutrient-dense than broth because of their higher concentration of amino acids. “Stock also does include collagen, which is helpful for the immune system, and it does have a higher concentration of minerals,”

So the question is, can I use broth and stock interchangeably?

If you only have broth and a recipe calls for stock, or vice versa, try not to stress too much over it.

According to Rumsey, “generally speaking, stock and broth can be used interchangeably with one another.” Although broth may not provide nearly as much body as stock, it will still certainly get the job done if you’re in a need. “There may just be minor changes in texture, but generally they’ll perform similarly.” Phew!


Great, now how do I make broth and stock?

The amount of time you have available as well as the components you already have on hand are the two primary considerations that should guide your decision regarding whether to prepare stock or broth. According to Gans, “stock is created mostly from the bones of animals (or fish), in addition to possibly some flesh, veggies (onion, celery, and carrots), and water.” In most cases, you won’t be adding any herbs or spices, and the cooking time will range from four to six hours.

Before using them to make stock, Chef Mathew Miller, director of banquets for Omni Hotels and formerly of Le Bernardin and Jean-Georges, suggests roasting the bones first.

Not only does making your own stock help you reduce the amount of food that goes to waste, but it also imparts additional flavor and nutrition to the food you prepare. “The great thing is you can use what people generally throw away—neck, joints, things that have a lot of collagen, oxtail, and short ribs,” Miller explained to Women’s Health in an earlier interview. “The collagen contributes to the thickening of the dish and makes it heartier than a thin stock or broth that you could get from the store. Additionally, it deepens the flavor of the dish.”

On the other hand, most of the components of broth include meat from animals, vegetables (onion, celery, and carrots), water, and various seasonings. Cooking time ranges from one hour and fifteen minutes to two hours.

It is well worth the effort to make your own broth or stock, even though doing so requires a time commitment of at least a couple of hours. According to Gans, “homemade might have slightly more nutrients than a commercially prepared one,” and this statement is based on speculation. Check out our chicken bone broth made from Melbourne chickens here.

From there, you may produce a wide variety of delectable homemade soups by using your own homemade broth and stock as the base.

Technically speaking, bone broth and stock are synonymous phrases that can be used in place of one another. On the other hand, bone broths are often merely boiled for a number of hours in order to extract additional nutrients from the bones and into the liquid.

It is important to remember that not all bone broths are prepared the same way. If a company uses bones in its broth, they have the right to call it “bone broth,” even if the bones and broth only come together for a brief period of time during the cooking process. At least four hours of simmering with the bones are required to make a good bone broth.

After being chilled, the broth ought to acquire a consistency similar to that of gel. This is a sign that the broth is of high quality and contains various nutrients such as collagen and amino acids.

Instead of buying bone broth already prepared or ready-made from the shop, you can consider preparing your own at home. Try your hand at making bone broth in a slow cooker by using bones from beef, venison, or fowl; alternatively, make bone broth from Thai coconut with fiery chiles, lemongrass, and ginger.

If you don’t have the ability to prepare your own, you can find several options of higher quality in the freezer department of the grocery store. During the freezing process, they will maintain their structure better. Amino acids and collagen can also be obtained in powdered or supplement form, which can be purchased. Examples of this include collagen peptides and bone broth powders.

Scroll to Top